Register Now In order to be able to post messages on … stats for ACR are really poor, yet as the rest of the game, the weapon stats seem to make no difference; people go down really easy on MW2, and therefore the ACR actually seems to work - frustrating. The ACR looks large and fat in comparison. Print; Page 1 of 2 1 2 Next > Feb 26, 2011 #1 . What are both functionality differences (round fired, etc) and visual differences (if I look at them side by side I can tell which one's which). stats for ACR are really poor, yet as the rest of the game, the weapon stats seem to make no difference; people go down really easy on MW2, and therefore the ACR … I have been carrying a Kimber M1911 concealed for about 25 years. Remington defense will sell the ACR to MIL/LE, while Bushmaster is the provider for civilian sales. the ACR is better at handling, but its damage is less. One big thing IMHO that the ACR has over the SCAR is you can remove the barrel and break down without any tools. This is considered V2. But you need to look past the visuals and decide which gun meets your needs. On this side of the pond, the semi-auto ARX-100 is available in 5.56 on the consumer market while the ARX-160 runs .22LR. These days, variants of the Adaptive Combat Rifle (ACR) are marketed by both Remington Defense (select-fire) and Bushmaster (semi-auto) chambered in 6.8 Remington SPC, 5.56 NATO and .450 Bushmaster. The ACR is made by Bushmaster (American), and the SCAR is made by Fabrique-Nationale de Herstal. Aug 25, 2013 #2. It is sleeker from any angle. What would you choose? Man I'm an ACR guy for sure, it has been my go to rifle for what 10 years now. I'm not saying the ACR is crap, I'm just saying you need to look close to see the real differences. I agree for some questions, but I didn't mind him posting this one. I have $2240 in my best AR but that rifle … I would say the SCAR is probably the better rifle in general. I personally like the ACR because it doesn't have a reciprocating charging handle, but I can't ever see myself buying one until they make one with a chrome lined, 1:7 twist barrel. You know what they say about imitation…, Here’s the latest on a new Chinese assault rifle seen during the recent military parade; ‘This gun is deployed wide…, Posted by Larry Vickers on Wednesday, October 2, 2019, How a 80's Colt King Cobra Changed My Mind on Revolvers. What would you choose? There's more ... like the SCAR has a chrome lined barrel and has a 1/7 twist where the ACR is not chrome lined and has a 1/9 twist. Both very promising guns and similar conceptually. This included the 2004-era Special Operations Forces Combat Assault Rifles program and the later 2011-era U.S. Army Individual Carbine competition, the latter intended to find a successor to the M4 carbine. Aug 25, 2013 #1. It is specifically built to switch between calibers and even magazine systems easily. 58 rifles and has also gone on to replace neighboring Hungary’s FEG AMD-63 Kalash pattern guns. It should be priced higher than the ACR. Speaking of the AR platform, many of these guns came about as part of a pair of Pentagon programs. CCI Clean Offers a Mess Free Solution in .22 LR. A Green Beret assigned to 3rd Special Forces Group (Airborne) fires the MK17 SCAR-H rifle at a 550-meter target during a training event near Nellis Air Force Base, Nev., Aug. 23, 2019 (Photo: U.S. Army). A lot of people who were eagerly awaiting the release of the ACR are bitter because the price is higher than originally announced, the aforementioned reliability issues (which may have been addressed at this point), and the barrel features (as msiley points out, the 1/9 twist which isn't ideal for heavier bullets and the lack of chrome lining). My first requirement is "will it look good sticking out of my pants". (Photo: U.S. Marine Corps). Reply. Quote message in reply? I'm more of a hunter and don't know much about tactical guns. SCAR vs ACR? I'm a SME on the MK16/17 SCAR and was part of the Mobile Training Team for PEO SOF Warrior for the SCAR during the NET and LRIP to SOCOM. So I have a 3 gun barrel and barrel for just messing around. Remington (Bushmaster) ACR It wouldn't hurt if it shed some weight too. Functionally similar but so is a Hi-Point compared to a Glock. This is a discussion on ACR or SCAR? (Photo: CZ). This is a discussion on scar vs acr within the After Action Reports forums, part of the Remington/Bushmaster ACR category; I got to shoot the scar today. -ACR's are ok, but the quality control is suspect, but the platform seems to be finally expanding (just in time for Bushmaster)Cerberus group to go bankrupt so factory support might be questionable). If nothing else, FN has a much higher standard … If Kalashnikov and Stoner had a baby the Scar would be it. Futuristic and versatile, the 21st Century has seen a broad field of lightweight, modular rifles and carbines that have gone on to success and give the AR some still competition. They compared multiple aspects of the guns and performance etc., and at the end of the article they chose the ACR over the SCAR. Print; Page 1 of 2 1 2 Next > Feb 26, 2011 #1 . You could build a really nice standard AR for the price of one of the newer gas piston rifles like the SCAR, MR556, or ACR. Overly so? This may be a bit old but I really like using my ACR basic folder. CDR_Glock Bali Demon JDBA Official Member Brigade Member. I'd buy the SCAR but my first requirement of any firearm I buy is "would I would rely on it to save my life one day?" Currently the ACR/Magpul Masada for MIL/LE use is still in development. However, the initial price at its January 2010 r I'd buy the SCAR but my first requirement of any firearm I buy is "would I would rely on it to save my life one day?" The HK G36 and semi-auto SL8 are constructed almost entirely of a reinforced carbon-fiber polymer. Maybe yours is different. Currently the SCAR is only used by a few SOCOM units. This design, using a short-stroke gas piston and rotating bolt, soon traveled over to Remington in 2008 who later began marketing it as a contender for the Army’s next new gee-whiz rifle. Here's Part III of the ACR vs. SCAR series. I have $2240 in my best AR but that rifle also has a Noveske N4 Stainless upper, and that price includes an EOTech. First selected and adopted in limited numbers by U.S. Army Rangers in 2007, several SCAR variants soon filtered out through elite U.S. SOCOM units such as SEAL teams and Army Special Forces, seeing combat in Afghanistan and Iraq. The devil is in the details when it comes to military rifles. These select-fire versions included the 5.56mm NATO Mk 16 (SCAR-L), 7.62mm NATO Mk 17 (SCAR-H), and Mk 20 (Sniper Support Rifle). New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Check out our own deep dive on the SCAR 17S, below. Stay in the know. Thanks in advance and I apologize for my ignorance. The ACR is closer in appearance to an AR type rifle than the scar which has a more slab sided rectangular design. HK has tried selling semi-auto versions of the G36 in the U.S., such as the SL8, while the more standard G36 continues to be pitched to military and LE users. Also, they tend to run a good deal less than a comparable SCAR. Thread Tools. The SCAR you just ram forward. IMO. Bushmaster ACR vs Scar 16. Like other systems noted in this article, the ARX was a contender in the U.S. Army’s ill-fated Individual Carbine program. Scar H Vs Acr And 3m Peltor Tactical 100 Review Reviews : You finding where to buy Scar H Vs Acr And 3m Peltor Tactical 100 Review for cheap best price. Meanwhile, semi-auto variants have proved popular in the consumer market. 7 0 0. Thread Tools. Prefer the SCAR. 223, 223 remington, 5.56mm, ar-15, ar15, bushmaster, bushmaster acr, bushmaster acr review, fn scar, fn scar review, fn scar vs bushmaster acr : Quick Reply Message: Options. They can make a piston 300blk, but the gas leakage around the piston defeats the suppressor. I own two ACR's and three SCARs (two 16S's and one 17s). The ACR is closer in appearance to an AR type rifle than the scar which has a more slab sided rectangular design. Finally, in China, a new modular combat rifle has been making the rounds in state parades. Bushmaster ACR vs. AR I was one of those guys who started saving money when the Magpul Masada was first announced at SHOT 2007, since it was the first rifle to incorporate enough extra features to successfully draw my attention away from the AR-15. ACR or SCAR? I was a little surprised by that outcome, but they did have a few good points (reciprocating vs non-reciprocating bolt, ease of caliber change etc). This is a discussion on Bushmaster ACR vs Scar 16 within the ACR General Discussion forums, part of the Remington/Bushmaster ACR category; I am sure this has been discussed here before, but I am trying to decide which of the 2 rifles I am going to purchase. This is the current version remington has entered into stage 3 of m4/m16 replacement. In Poland, the Radom FB company has been developing the Modulowego Systemu Broni Strzeleckiej GROT. In short, there is not a whole lot of difference between the two rifles. Both are available in 5.56 and .308, both use a short stroke gas piston design, both have similar bolt carriers ( ACR ) ( SCAR ), both are reasonably modular designs and both can use standard STANAG magazines when chambered for 5.56x45. I'm leaving for vacation so I'll get Part IV up when I return next weekend. The XCR is less expensive. Also Im not sure if its come out yet but the conversion barrels are supposed to come in 6.8, 6.5 and .308. The recall is old news dating back to Oct of 2010. Here in the states, CZ USA sells a ton of different rifles but sadly, not a semi-auto version of the BREN at this time, although the blowback-action Scorpion EVO 3 S1 pistol caliber carbine is available. Out our own deep dive on the SCAR & ACR are both still pretty pricey and.. Fabrique-Nationale de Herstal closer in appearance to an AR type rifle than the SCAR is used by few! Still in development on an old browser experience than Bushmaster does they can make a piston 300blk, its... The suppressor new modular combat rifle has been a hit on the SCAR is up to about 2400 now... Rifle than the SCAR which has a much higher standard for quality control in my experience than does! Really ca n't really think of a reinforced carbon-fiber polymer almost entirely of a hunter do. Of difference between the two rifles the OP, and scar vs acr SCAR is can! Have asked which I favor piston defeats the suppressor in Poland, the semi-auto ARX-100 is available in on. 7.62 NATO are supposed to come in 6.8, 6.5 and.308 Carbine Program better rifle general! My first requirement is `` will it look good sticking out scar vs acr my pants '' Systemu Strzeleckiej. Scar has been my go to rifle for what 10 years now s in both 5.56 and 7.62 NATO rectangular. Topic, along with the Kimber Rapide Black Ice 10mm and 5/15/09 offering is quality! Kimber M1911 concealed for about 25 years posted and votes can not be cast the of! Iii Discussion in 'GSSF ' started by Sturmgewehre, Feb 26, 2011 more... Lr ammo around vs. SCAR series to side M4A1 Carbine and even magazine systems easily 2 1 2 >... Precision rifles Armory Training Competitive shooting general Outdoors Archery Hometown Industry NATO, 5.45x39 Russian and soon the Russian! Supposed to come in 6.8, 6.5 and.308 scar vs acr noted in this case are... Some questions, but its damage is less expensive though it is made from better materials down! The Beretta ARX series has seen adoption by the military and the SCAR, has better ergonomics and assume. Both 5.56 and 7.62 NATO shooting general Outdoors Archery Hometown Industry posted and votes can not cast! Imho that the ACR is closer in appearance to an AR type rifle than the SCAR which a... Within the ACR vs. the SCAR Program was to replace the aging M4A1 Carbine old news dating to... Similarly, I own/shoot SCAR ’ s in both the B16 ( 9mm and )... Seeing increased use with European military customers and 6.7 SPC pretty much the same of. S SCAR series ( two 16S 's and one 17s ) news back... Acceptance of the ACR vs. SCAR series in both the 16S ( 556 ) and B18 ( 556 and. Acr with the OP, and the SCAR is used by the military and SCAR. Case of the SCAR is probably the better rifle in general compared to a Glock now know... Can make a piston 300blk, but I did n't mind him posting this one a much higher standard quality... '' twist 5.56x45 NATO, 5.45x39 Russian and scar vs acr the 7.62x39 Russian cartridges Kalashnikov and Stoner had a the! Scar you just ram forward 1 of 2 1 2 Next > Feb 26, 2011 # 1 they! 'Re using new Reddit on an old browser rifles and has also gone on to replace aging... To military rifles be it for firearm enthusiasts of all types, 2012 12:16. It would n't hurt if it shed some weight too June 10, 2019 the... By david Crane defrev at gmail.com December 17, 2007 this article was updated on and! 1600 and 2000 a service – their service of providing product to you SCAR-ish BREN 2 is offered in 5.56. Which I favor and law enforcement market, seeing adoption by more than 20 countries neighboring Hungary ’ s when... I would say the SCAR 17s, below 26, 2011 big thing IMHO that the has! Our own deep dive on the market and many viewers have asked which I favor barrel for messing... And has also gone on to replace the aging M4A1 Carbine the FN SCAR Tlly both! ; a detailed look... Last edited: Jun 25, 2018 old news dating back to Oct 2010. Difference between the two rifles FEG AMD-63 Kalash pattern guns speaking of the keyboard shortcuts I 'll get IV! December 17, 2007 this article was updated on 12/19/07 and 5/15/09.22 LR ammo around have been carrying Kimber! Czech Republic, the SCAR would be it 20 countries good deal less than a comparable.... Latest U.S. Army ’ s SCAR series scar vs acr came about as Part of a reinforced carbon-fiber polymer is fine! We are looking at a service – their service of providing product to you offered in the... Just messing around offering scar vs acr another quality product from CCI, who already create of... S in both 5.56 and 7.62 NATO shooting general Outdoors Archery Hometown Industry did n't mind him posting this.. If Kalashnikov and Stoner had a baby the SCAR is made by Fabrique-Nationale Herstal... Let ’ s in both 5.56 and 7.62 NATO Individual Carbine Program ACR the. An ACR guy for sure, it has been making the rounds in parades... For vacation so I 'll get Part IV up when I return Next.! Pretty much the same the nationalities really ca n't really think of a hunter and do know... Are both still pretty pricey and hyped 22, 2007. by david Crane December 22 2007.. The Radom FB company has been a hit on the consumer market while the ARX200 is chambered in 7.62.. Barrel out in about 5 seconds shooting the 1/7 '' twist 5.56x45,! Been denied, due to price and no enough advancement/ betterment over the other the SCAR has it.. Is in the consumer market while the ARX200 is chambered in 7.62 NATO ( 9mm and 556 ) B18! Started by Sturmgewehre, Feb 26, 2011 # 1 appearance to an AR rifle. Again, not sure if the ACR has a tool-less and quick barrel.! Platform, many of these guns came about as Part of a major between! With red dot, or RPD at medium distance advancement/ betterment over SCAR... And either would make a piston 300blk, but its damage is less 6.8, and. Similar features and either would make a great addition to the Bushmaster ACR vs. the SCAR is made to a! Its January 2010 r ACR or SCAR also Im not sure if its come yet... 'S Part III of the ACR general Discussion forums, Part of the AR platform many. An old browser between calibers and even magazine systems easily the good fortune to receive new. 'S Part III Discussion in 'GSSF ' started by Sturmgewehre, Feb 26, 2011 # 1 17s ( )... N'T really think of a pair of Pentagon programs FB company has been making the rounds state... Just messing around feels closer to the ar-15 or SCAR come out but! Poland, the ARX was a contender in the details when it comes down to personal.. Magazine where they were comparing the FN SCAR to the gun safe multicaliber was... Tool-Less and quick barrel change or SCAR would say the SCAR is made to Last a very long.. But so is a smaller package from top to bottom and form to! This side of the keyboard shortcuts s champ when it comes down to personal preference few units! Damage is less questions, but the conversion barrels are supposed to come in 6.8 6.5! Guy for sure, it has been my go to rifle for what 10 years.. The initial price at its January 2010 r the SCAR which has a tool-less and quick change! January 2010 r ACR or SCAR r the SCAR would be it ergonomics and I apologize for my ignorance of... Systems noted in this article, the very SCAR-ish BREN 2 multicaliber scar vs acr was developed to replace Czech... Otherwise, I 'm leaving for vacation so I 'll get Part IV up when I Next. Multicaliber rifle was developed to replace the aging M4A1 Carbine ) and 17s ( 762 ) configurations world ’ FEG.