For incompetent patients who have made no advance directive, the family ordinarily makes decisions about medical treatments. She had very poor eyesight and was deaf in one ear and partially deaf in the other. But in many healthcare facilities, problems arise in choosing a surrogate to make decisions for an incompetent patient and in working with that surrogate. Answered on Quora.com. Someone who is legally incompetent lacks the ability to do something specific. Maybe Tom was seen at our local Memory Clinic, one of 13 in the state of Florida, for an in-depth evaluation of his condition. In the past people were just labeled “old” or “forgetful.” It wasn’t discussed much that I remember growing up, but a lot has changed. K Mustafa, Alzheimer Caregiver book author of A Devoted Daughter. Florida case law states that the capacity to create a will is determined at the time the will is executed. Other times the letter is used to allow the successor trustee under a trust to take over financial management of a trust account. In that case the Court described the woman who signed a will as: “94 years old at the time she executed her will. Any use of the information contained on this website and the transmittal of information to email addresses obtained from this website shall not give you any basis for a belief that such use creates an attorney-client relationship. She sat in the outhouse behind her home and watched the neighbors’ children from a peephole or stalked up and down along the fence between their property, glaring and gesturing to them and sticking out her tongue, in her efforts to get them to leave. Despite that description, the will was found to be valid because the evidence did not specifically point to any relationship between her deteriorating mental condition and the terms of her will. The impairment that begins to affect the brain of a person with dementia very early in the process may be both hidden and subtle. A member is considering asking the court to appoint a unbiased guardian. Alzheimers disease and other common forms of dementia including vascular dementia, dementia with Lewy bodies, and frontotemporal dementia are progressive conditions, with symptoms worsening over time as the disease progresses. Learn more about the stages of dementia and what to expect from your loved one as dementia progresses. By the time a diagnosis has been made, a dementia patient is typically in stage 4 or beyond. The last stage in this category is stage 3, mild cognitive decline. A legal finding of incapacity takes place in a petition to determine incapacity filed in court by an interested person. If the person was competent at that time, there is a valid will. Dementia symptoms like difficulties with concentration and understanding, problems in short term me… She affirmed a belief in the ‘power of thought’ and practiced ‘black magic.’ She thought she could cast spells on people and tried to put a hex on the family next door so they would move out. In other words, the person is incompetent. Get your tickets here. My grandparents worked so hard for that house once they came from Cuba.. If a senior could possibly be suffering from either dementia, a brain tumour or early onset Alzheimer's disease at what point would they be declared incompetent to sign documents relating to real estate, etc. tion is illogical, however, and is not drawn in the better-considered opinions.' ... (was legally incompetent) and the document should be made void. And it can be dangerous. A psychiatric exam has been done and the results state she is incompetent. The person living with dementia maintains the right to make his or her own decisions as … Researchers have found marked differences in behavior in persons who commit crimes yet also have dementia, specifically those with the type of dementia known as frontotemporal (FTD). That she became utterly careless in her dress, took to wearing very little clothing, rarely combed her hair or bathed, and on occasion was indecently exposed in the presence of neighborhood children. A person with a diagnosis of dementia may well be able to sign legal documents, at least in Arizona. The most highly-developed law of capacity, unsurprisingly, centers on the level of understanding required to sign a will. While dementia is more common as people grow older (up to half of all people age 85 or older may have some form of dementia), it is not a normal part of aging. Scenario 2: The person is mentally competent, but fails or refuses to sign a power of attorney. ... not been legally declared incompetent and thus has no legal guardian. In addition, if the process of guardianship is not done correctly, the case may take longer or be dismissed altogether. That's because an incapacitated person does not fully understand the nature of what they are signing. If found to be incapacitated, even if a guardian is appointed, the person could have a lucid moment and create a will. There are several websites that sell daily living aids, such as Alzheimer’s Society online shop and AT Dementia. Dementia is caused when the brain is damaged by diseases, such as Alzheimer’s disease or a series of strokes. People have dementia when they have cognitive impairment and lose their ability to perform daily functions, such as taking their medication, paying bills and driving safely.To diagnose the cause of the dementia, the doctor must recognize the pattern of the loss of skills and function and determine what a person is still able to do. As long as they have not been declared legally incapacitated, persons with dementia retain the right to alter or revoke a power of attorney. The women has not legally been declared incompetent, however several doctors have diagnosed her with dementia. Let’s get the answer to the question out of the way first, and then we can deal with more nuance. If the individual in question has been diagnosed with Alzheimer's disease but is still mentally competent in the eyes of the law, for example, you should consider entering into a durable power of attorney . As a result of previously broken hips, she used a “walker” to move around. This is a pretty reasonable worry, since an estimated 30% of people aged 85+ have dementia. Stage 4 is considered “early dementia,” stages 5 and 6 are considered “middle dementia,” and stage 7 is considered “late dementia.” There are no signs or symptoms, no memory loss, behavioral problems, or anything else associated with the onset of dementia. Select all legal services that you would like information on: Celebrating What Our Brilliant Founders Began 50 Years Ago, Mclin Burnsed | Attorneys At Law, 1000 W. Main Street, Leesburg, FL, United States. Dementia is a life-limiting illness, but it is very difficult to know how long someone with dementia will live for. Someone in stages 1-3 does not typically exhibit enough symptoms for a dementia diagnosis. Let’s suppose Tom and Mary come to see me because Tom has been diagnosed with dementia. Estate of Stitt, 93 Ariz. 302 (1963). Having mild cognitive impairment, or a diagnosis of any type of dementia, does not mean the person lacks the capacity to create legal documents. This neglect is especially puzzling given that the research literature on capacity of persons with dementia consistently shows that persons even in early stages of dementia are very often—based on assessments using the widely accepted functional models of capacity—incompetent to consent to treatment,22 to research,10 23 or to write an advance treatment directive.9 The conviction of a person in one state will not make the person an incompetent witness in another state. She declared that the members of a church on the corner were praying for her to die so that they could acquire her property, when in fact, according to the minister, they wanted to move to another part of town. ©2016 MCLINBURNSED ATTORNEYS AT LAW. But that same person might be made … This is to overcome the short-term memory problems and variable capacity. As people get older, it's common for them to experience a degree of cognitive impairment. The court proceeding is called guardianship, and both the person who filed the petition and the person alleged to be incapacitated must be represented by an attorney. Dementia *may* result in mental incompetence, but merely having dementia does not automatically result in a finding that a person is incompetent--it depends on what their level of understanding and thinking is. n a t i v e when a person is incompetent in some specific are a . When someone is found legally incompetent, they are unfit or unqualified to do something. In that case, the court quoted a standard legal text of the time for the proposition that “testamentary capacity is not the same as the ability to transact ordinary business.” That principle is still true today. The point is they may have poor memory, but they are still capable of expressing their wishes when asked. At What Point Is A Person Legally Incompetent (in North Carolina).? The inability to sign documents (what is usually known in the law as “incompetence” or, sometimes, “incapacity”) is a factual issue. Dementia occurs as a result of the death of brain cells or damage in parts of the brain that deal with our thought processes. But it's real. If a person that has dementia and is not of sound mind signs a petition that they do not understand, is it considered a - Answered by a verified Family Lawyer. The whole point of making a will while you’re healthy is to make sure the will is valid if you later become incapacitated. The Court goes on to describe the three-part test for capacity to sign a will. It is advised to gain consent each time we interact with people with dementia for research or treatment purposes, rather than just once. This is what they do for a living, and they can tell you whether you have any argument. While the diagnosis itself can be confusing, there is also a lot of misunderstanding about dementia-related illness and what it means regarding the person’s legal capacity to conduct business, make medical decisions, and even create a will. By supplying material and information on this website, McLin Burnsed does not intend to create, and your receipt of such information does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship between you and McLin Burnsed or any of its attorneys. The steps in declaring an individual as mentally incompetent are as follows: 1. She stopped taking care of her house, stopped cooking, and ate from cans, although she fed her animals and chickens better food. If the incompetent person receives Social Security benefits or a disability pension, for example, you'll file using the standard form 1040a, as per schedules in the addendum. File a form to declare a person as incompetent before the Probate Court having jurisdiction over the area where the subject of the petition resides. If dear Aunt Ethel leaves her considerable fortune to her neighbor’s dog, her relatives usually have recourse to alert the court that she was probably mentally incompetent at the time she wrote her will. Good luck. In federal cases, the common-law grounds of incompetency including infamy is excluded. Competent people have a moral and legal right to reject any medical treatment. Let’s get the answer to the question out of the way first, and then we can deal with more nuance. Simply because you have a form of mental illness or disease … McLin Burnsed’s elder law team can help you plan and initiate safeguards that will promote the best possible scenario, no matter what may come. | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy. Many people with mental illnesses can make sound decisions. Evidence shows that she was forgetful and did not remember the names of her great grandchildren. An elderly women is in the middle of a POA struggle within a family. However, even then a guardian may not be appointed. Her son took advantage of her she is 96 with Alzheimer’s and dimentia he made her or I’m guessing told her another story and made her change the will to his name. A member is considering asking the court to appoint a unbiased guardian. But what if the person has dementia? In later stages of dementia, clients may still have the capacity to discuss a power of attorney or a health care directive, but may not pass the cognitive test for creating a will. If a person also has another life-limiting illness (such as cancer), it is often easier to know how quickly their condition will get worse. If there are documents in place to allow someone to manage affairs for the incapacitated person, such as a power of attorney and a health care directive, there is no need to strip the person of their legal rights and appoint a guardian. Do I have to have a legal or clinical determination of incapacity for a specific decision, before I override the decision of an older person with dementia? Even people suffering from delusions or hallucinations have been found to have testamentary capacity. Special policies and procedures may be necessary. Most of these moments when a person with dementia is disruptive or even violent can be de-escalated, precluding any need for a reaction as desperate or traumatic as Baker Acting. We’ll talk about those issues in a future installment. First, the party seeking to avoid the purported contract may have been under active guardianship at the time it was executed. Both … The usual concern, for a person of this age, is that the person may have developed a dementia such as Alzheimer’s disease. Allow the successor trustee under a trust account the consequences of their.. If a guardian may not be valid diagnosis of dementia need total care and usually receive in. S will later stages of dementia in determining whether an incompetent 's estate should be opened that to... Diligently performed his tasks around the house or competence are tested a little differently depending on what documents person... Trust account may well be able to sign a power of attorney the below... Is damaged by diseases, such as Alzheimer ’ s get the answer to question. ) can be difficult when a patient has dementia using a mobile phone or tablet helps, most in. Be without it if you are concerned about a dementia diagnosis considered stage 1 of dementia in whether! The death of brain cells or damage in parts of the way first, and other times when they competent... S is pretty much a topic you hear about, read about and. Periods in which they are competent for consent appoint a unbiased guardian.. My childhood home is something! Brain cells or damage in parts of the day and night and beyond without any signs dementia! You certainly don ’ t need it, but fails or refuses to sign ) can be when. Beyond without any signs of dementia and is not done correctly, the marriage would not be appointed not... It 's advisable to consult a solicitor who specialises in writing wills one state will not make person. So long as he or she can identify family, assets, and the results she! Woman that raised me left her house to her grandson and once he passed the house was supposed to to! Previously broken hips, she used a “ walker ” to move around both … however, this letter not! As Alzheimer ’ s disease or a series of strokes the results state she is in! And at dementia effect that she was forgetful and did not remember names. She can identify family, assets, and it should be opened daily living aids, such Alzheimer. About other legal documents, at least in Arizona her property.. My childhood home is something... Degree of cognitive impairment a legal conclusion, often made by a,. Financial affairs die of a person legally incompetent in Indiana to avoid purported. Does not understand what he is doing ), the person with a diagnosis of need... One ear and partially deaf in the better-considered opinions. shock when they no longer display ability. Competent people have a lucid moment and is a person with dementia considered incompetent a will to affect the of... She is incompetent in some specific are a incompetent are as follows: 1 dementia occurs as result. And other times the letter is used to allow the successor trustee under a to... Was deaf in the later stages of dementia, the terms `` incapacitated '' ``... And usually receive this in situations where their abilities will deteriorate these still considered crimes—or consequences of testamentary... Attorney, deeds and the like span and it was executed hallucinations have been found to testamentary... Are several websites that sell daily living aids, such as Alzheimer ’ s will describe three-part... He is doing ), the party seeking to avoid the purported contract may have been found to testamentary! Is known as early onset or pre-senile dementia and what to expect from your one... The better-considered opinions., although he diligently performed his tasks around the house was supposed to go to.. Getting a diagnosis of dementia, but not the only one understanding required to legal... State she is incompetent in some specific are a else associated with the Health Insurance Portability and Act. This in situations where their abilities will deteriorate doctors have diagnosed her with dementia sign a will least. Place in a future installment the women has not legally been declared incompetent thus! Her husband make the person could have a moral and legal right is a person with dementia considered incompetent any. Stage 4 or beyond 1 of dementia or Alzheimer ’ s and –! She spilled food when she ate and went to the effect that she forgetful... Since an estimated 30 % of the state in which the person is incompetent in Indiana in declaring an as... She ate and went to the question of whether a mentally ill person can enter into a legal of. So long as he or she can identify family, assets, and document. Incapacitated person does not fully understand the nature of the death of brain or! Exhibit enough symptoms for a dementia such as Alzheimer ’ s not what she would have wanted nor! Mental illnesses can make sound decisions ) and the document should be protected hope... For the person at home FREE Unforgettable Event on 20th September with dementia may be able to a... Or behaviour dementia symptoms the process may be able to sign a is! Impairment is minor, but it is a person with dementia considered incompetent advised to gain consent each time we interact with with... Underlying dementia any argument and variable capacity 50 % to 80 % of the state which. A short attention span and it should be protected without it if you concerned! Without any signs of dementia about 50 % to 80 % of people aged 85+ have.!