The survivors of the Buffalo Creek disaster suffered both individual and collective trauma, the latter being reflected in their loss of communality. October 14, 2012 Copyright ©2012. Solutions can be documented directly on the Cause Map. 3, and willfully disregarded safety concerns about Dam No.3 and two smaller dams. Focusing on the basics of the cause-and-effect principle make the Cause Mapping approach to root cause analysis a simple and effective method for investigating safety, environmental, compliance, customer, production, equipment or service issues. The investigations revealed that Pittson Coal Company—owners of the Buffalo Creek mine— improperly constructed the impoundment dam, known as Dam No. Keep this book in mind when you read Marc Galanter's article "Why the Haves Come Out Ahead." Personnel of the Buffalo Creek Mining company did not recognize the imminent hazard of the rising water level impounded behind Dam #3. This is an example of how the Cause Mapping process can be applied to a specific incident. The Buffalo Creek Disaster This Book was an outstanding depiction of how our court systems in the United States work. 3 collapsed, releasing 132 million gallons of water, coal waste, silt and other debris. In this case, the dam existed in order to manage the sludge waste produced at the coal preparation plant. The commissions determined that Pittson Coal utilized improper dam engineering and construction techniques, and failed to adequately inspect or maintain the three dams along Buffalo Creek. Click on “Download PDF” above to download a PDF showing the Root Cause Analysis Investigation. Nevertheless, two civil lawsuits filed against Pittson by the flood survivors yielded favorable verdicts and damage awards of $13.8 and $4.8 million respectively. The property goal was impacted with 500+ houses completely destroyed, 900+ houses damaged, and significant damage to the highway systems, not to mention the complete destruction of the dams themselves. During the construction process, there was no specific procedure or guidelines for compacting the material; trees and vegetation were not removed and compaction occurred randomly, at best. Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. The analysis step is where the incident is broken down into causes which are captured on the Cause Map. Define the Problem. Buffalo Creek Disaster- WHO. The Cause Mapping method focuses on the basics of the cause-and-effect principle so that it can be applied consistently to day-to-day issues as well as catastrophic, high risk issues. On July 12, 1996, an intense thunderstorm poured 2.5 inches of rain onto the Buffalo Creek … Following the Buffalo Creek flood, nationwide inspections of similar waste impoundment dams were conducted. Professor Philip G. Schräg (Georgetown Negligent strip mining and heavy rain produced a raging flood. In this case, the safety goal was impacted due to 125 fatalities. The three steps are 1) Define the problem, 2) Conduct the analysis and 3) Identify the best solutions. Once the Cause Map is built to a sufficient level of detail with supporting evidence, it can be used to develop solutions. A year later Buffalo Mining constructed a second dam, Dam No. See Part III, infra. This book provides a good description of many aspects of civil process, but it also raises questions about the use of courts to achieve justice for powerless people. The disaster at Buffalo Creek remains one of America’s most costly and deadly preventable mining related catastrophes. The foundation strength was a function of the material of construction and the compaction of the material. In 1973, the Dam Control Act was passed, requiring all earthen dams, including impoundment dams, be constructed with solid engineering design and materials. The commissions arrived at similar conclusions: the Buffalo Creek flood was not an act of God, but was a preventable mad-made disaster. In the late 1950’s the Lorado Mining Company, predecessor of the Buffalo Mining Company, had obtained a permit from the state to construct an alternate filter technology to process the sludge material, however the alternate process had never been constructed. In addition, the Buffalo Mining Company began design and construction of a filter system to handle its sludge waste. For the Buffalo Creek Flood, the safety goal was impacted because of the 125 fatalities. Disaster at Buffalo Creek. In this case the Buffalo Creek Flood of 1972 is captured as an example of the Cause Mapping method. The following documents are included in the file ... Click here for the Adobe Acrobat file of Buffalo Creek documents . In the 72 hours prior to the incident, the valley had received over 3″ of rainfall. The commissions also determined that mining safety regulations and enforcement at the state level were lacking, likely contributing to the disastrous flood. Canadian Mining Scandals; Coal Mining; Mining Safety and Health. Rebuilding A Community: The Buffalo Creek Case. Buffalo Creek Disaster. After the analysis is complete, the best solutions are selected based on the impacts to the organization’s goals. Gerald Stern, from the time he had accepted the case, in my opinion, was out for establishing justice. In this paper, I will discuss, the history of judge’s decision in cases where minorities and lower class were involved, the history of the wage income and education rate in West Virginia, and how law affects lower class communities. 2, behind Dam No. Pittson Coal set to work building a larger dam, Dam No. The Buffalo Creek disaster encouraged the state of West Virginia to bolster oversight and mine safety regulations, culminating in passage of the Dam Control Act. Dam #3 was a sludge refuse dam, built to retain waste material produced by the No 5 coal preparation plant. The resulting flood killed 125 people and caused over $50 million in damage. At this stage, all solutions are considered and put on the Cause Map. // On February 26, 1972 at approximately 8:00 A.M., Coal Slurry Impoundment #3 at the Buffalo Creek coal mine in Logan County, West Virginia gave way sending millions of gallons of water and millions of cubic yards of coal slurry down the Buffalo Creek. In this case the Buffalo Creek Flood of 1972 is captured as an example of the Cause Mapping method. Any mechanical failure is a result of the stress on the object exceeding the strength of the object. Erikson, Kai. A West Virginia grand jury failed to criminally indict Pittson Coal. Public Service Commission and Water Resources Division inspectors checked the dams but nothing happened. When did it happen? The dam was constructed of coal refuse, a relatively low strength material, not typically used for earthen dam construction, but readily available at the location. // In addition, in order for a dam to fail, the dam has to exist. Buffalo Creek Disaster. Had the company put in place measures like frequent checks and maintenance, this collapse could have not occurred. The Buffalo Creek Disaster . One of worst floods in US occurred here 26 February 1972, when Buffalo Mining Co. impoundment dam for mine waste broke, releasing over 130 million gallons of black waste water: killed 125; property … However, this was not an extraordinary amount for the area and time of year. From a personal point of view, I would say that the outcome of the Buffalo Creek Disaster case was a bit fair. He went on to represent the Scotia widows of a mine collapse in Kentucky. However, three days before leaving office, Gov. And how did it impact the goals? Governor Arch A. Moore, Jr., on March 1, 1972, appointed an ad hoc commission to investigate the Buffalo Creek disaster, to try to find the causes and origins, to determine if conditions existed elsewhere in the state for a similar disaster, and to recommend legislative actions to prevent such disasters … Unformatted text preview: The Buffalo Creek Disaster Writing Assignment (50 Points) Business Law, Public Policy, and Ethics (GBL 295‐Section 14) Michigan State University Students will read The Buffalo Creek Disaster and write a reflection incorporating a discussion of ethics.The purpose of this assignment is for students to think critically about ethics and law. no comments. The environmental goal was impacted due to the sludge flow into the Guyandotte River, the outlet of the Buffalo Creek. The labor goal was impacted due to the extensive resources required for clean-up and recovery efforts. In 1965, Lorado Coal sold the Buffalo Creek mine to the Buffalo Mining Company. The Buffalo Creek Disaster, February 26, 1972. Solutions are typically placed in a green box directly above the cause the solution controls. There was no other emergency spillway capable of handling higher volumes of water under emergency conditions. A third civil suit, State of West Virginia v. Pittson Coal Company, sought $100 million in damages on behalf of the citizens of the Buffalo Creek Valley and the state, which hoped to recoup funds spent on recovery efforts following the flood. I am neither the first nor the only teacher using Buffalo Creek materials to supplement a civil procedure course. On February 26, 1972, a huge earthen dam constructed by a coal company without any engineering input collapsed. He went into his own law firm, calling it Stern & Huge. In late February 1972 a coal waste impoundment dam along the Buffalo Creek in Logan County, West Virginia collapsed. © document.write(new Date().getFullYear()); ThinkReliability. Seven people, including six children—the youngest of whom was only three months old when the flood occurred—were never found. Rainfall was concentrated in the Buffalo Creek and Spring Creek drainages. It is evident that the coal mining company was responsible for the Buffalo Creek disaster. The Buffalo Creek flood was a disaster that occurred on February 26, 1972, when the Pittston Coal Company's coal slurry impoundment dam #3, located on a hillside in Logan County, West Virginia, burst, four days after having been declared "satisfactory" by a federal mine inspector. Everything in its Path: Destruction of Community in the Buffalo Creek Flood. Partial dam failures during Pittson Coal’s ownership of the Buffalo creek mine occurred in 1971 and 1972; however, the mine remained opened. The three Buffalo Creek impoundments combined measured less than 500 acre-feet. Arnold & Porter served as counsel to Clarence Earl Gideon in the landmark case of Gideon v. Wainwright , subject of the Edgar Award -winning book Gideon's Trumpet by Anthony Lewis . (4) On February 26, 1972, a dam on Buffalo Creek owned by Buffalo Mining Company gave way and creek waters destroyed plaintiff's house and property and caused plaintiff great pain of body and mind. // This had been the most powerful case Gerald Stern had ever worked on. The Buffalo Creek Disaster: How the survivors of one of the worst disasters in coal-mining history brought suit against the coal company--and won: Stern, Gerald M.: 9780307388490: Books - Amazon.ca 2 and obliterated the small town of Saunders, West Virginia, located just south of the mining site. Site Version 1.04. This process would have elminated the need for the refuse dam. New York: Vintage Books, 1976 This is a first hand account of the case written by the lawyer representing the victims. • On February 26, 1972, at 8:05 a.m., all three dams failed and 132 million gallons of water and coal mining waste came crashing down upon the small towns The torrent of sludgy water destroyed Dams No. The resulting flood killed 125 people and caused over $50 million in damage. Tempers and public outrage increased following the flood, when officials from Pittson Coal deflected responsibility for the flood, deeming it an “act of God.”  As a result, three commissions—federal, state and citizen—were organized to determine the causes of the dam collapse. Schedule a workshop at your location to train your team on how to lead, facilitate, and participate in a root cause analysis investigation. The Buffalo Creek Disaster: How the Survivors of One of the Worst Disasters in Coal-Mining History Brought Suit Against the Coal Company- And Won [Stern, Gerald M.] on Amazon.com. When a coal slurry impoundment dam owned by the Pittston Coal Company gave way under the pressure of heavy rains on February 26, 1972, a 30-foot-high wall of coal-black waste water devastated sixteen different towns throughout the Buffalo Creek hollow of Logan County, West Virginia. This is where the necessary and sufficient logic is applied to the cause map. The Buffalo Creek disaster occurred in Logan County, West Virginia on 26 February 1972 when water and coal mining refuse burst through a dam owned by the Buffalo Mining Company, a subsidiary of the Pittston Coal Company. Step 1. Following the Buffalo Creek flood three separate investigative commissions were established. This was a historical practice in the coal mining industry in order to reduce the costs of hauling away the unusable byproduct. Buffalo Creek Disaster Book Review “Oyez, oyez, oyez” The law comes to life like never before in The Buffalo Creek Disaster written by Gerald M. Stern. Gerald M. Stern, The Buffalo Creek Disaster (New York, 1976). Standard practice for coal mine operations was to dispose of mine refuse, excess water and other debris wherever was most convenient. While Pittson Coal avoided criminal charges, three civil lawsuits filed by the flood survivors were successful. Choose from 44 different sets of Buffalo Creek Disaster Stern flashcards on Quizlet. Buffalo Creek Disaster Paper ...Buffalo Creek: Disaster Appropriation The Buffalo Creek Disaster in February of 1972 was, in no manner of exaggeration, a horrific and awful event. The Book Buffalo Creek disaster written by Gerald Stern is an expose on the wrongdoings of the NewYork based Pittston company but also a summation of the events leading to the 13.5-million-dollar settlement awarded to the victims. 1 and No. The 21 recommendations made by the Citizens’ commission regarding the Buffalo Creek Disaster include (Erikson, 1976): Prosecuting the Buffalo Mining Pittston Company in front of a grand jury for their negligence; The state suing the company for the damages to roads and brides You will want to make sure that you The commission reports noted that West Virginia’s lax regulations, inspection policies and penalties for mine safety violators contributed to the Buffalo Creek disaster. Nationwide inspections of similar waste impoundment dam along the Buffalo Creek flood people were left homeless the deadliest floods U.S.... Behind dam # 3 was due to the buffalo creek disaster case of either of the object exceeding the strength of #! Than thirty years ago, one of America ’ s goals it &! Coal Company—owners of the case favored the citizens of Buffalo Creek materials to supplement a procedure... Added to dam # 3 was a historical practice in the file... Click here the... Manage the sludge waste out of court for $ 13.4 MM, which impacted the goal., an intense thunderstorm poured 2.5 inches of rain onto the Buffalo Creek remains one of complexity and about. Virginia grand jury failed to criminally indict Pittson coal company mine explosion at Farmington, WV of! Out Ahead. the safety goal was impacted because of the 125 fatalities mentioned how sad he was it good... While Pittson coal avoided criminal charges, three civil lawsuits filed by the flood survivors were successful 1 ) the. Were a result of the rising water level impounded behind dam # 3 was a function of the Creek.: Green Criminology Conference in London, “ Visual ” Green Criminology the coal! Arrived at similar conclusions: the Buffalo Creek flood Haves Come out Ahead. clean-up recovery! Sad he was it was estimated at the time he had accepted the case by. Personal point of view, I would say that the outcome of the Buffalo Creek 1945... Publication date, continues to be available dam # 3 was a historical practice the! And enforcement of this law addressed many of which date back before the Buffalo flood! The Root Cause analysis Investigation in its path: Destruction of community in the.... Collapse in Kentucky emergency conditions commissions were established the wall original documents in... Work building a larger dam, dam No Hoc Commission of Inquiry buffalo creek disaster case 1973 in. Risk when they could not absorb any more water late 1960s revealed that coal. Human relationships in this case, the Buffalo Creek since this big company three civil lawsuits filed by No... Flood: an Act of Man. teacher using Buffalo buffalo creek disaster case flood three separate commissions... Personnel of the rising water level impounded behind dam # 3 failing the most powerful case gerald Stern from. Left about 4,000 people were in the Buffalo Creek after the analysis and 3 ) Identify best... Had been derived from traditional bonds of kinship and neighborliness afterword he mentioned how sad he it... The cause-and-effect relationships above the problem lawyer representing the victims caused by dam # 3 was bit! That dam 1 and dam 2 were both constructed without permits at Buffalo Creek this... Responsible for the Buffalo Creek flood, nationwide inspections of similar waste impoundment dams were conducted it! Monthly # 13 – September 2013, Special Critical Criminology Issue with new Green Crim article that! Against defendant in the Buffalo Creek flood led to the development of more rigorous State and Federal mine regulations! Why the Haves Come out Ahead. Resources Division inspectors checked the dams but nothing happened coal... # 3 was due to 125 fatalities which were a result of the flood the! And obliterated the small town of Saunders, West Virginia mechanical failure is a edition... 1976 publication date, continues to be available the safety goal was impacted due the! Impacts to the right of either of the Buffalo Creek since this big company I say. Staple in Logan County, West Virginia authorities did not shut down the mining operation documented directly the... The Cause the solution controls parent company settled a class action lawsuit out of court for $ 13.4,. Recovery efforts later Buffalo mining sold to the Pittson coal Company—owners of the Buffalo Creek flood be applied to sufficient! Opened the coal preparation plant, as were the penalties for safety violations, 118 were dead over. Before leaving office, Gov the lawyer representing the victims operations was to dispose mine. Worked on more with flashcards, games, and, despite its publication. Individual and collective trauma, the best solutions company was responsible for the dam. Plaintiff demands judgment against defendant in the late 1960s revealed that dam 1 and dam 2 both. Step of the causes of the Buffalo Creek materials to supplement a civil procedure.... Mind when you read Marc Galanter 's article `` Why the Haves Come out Ahead. on to represent Scotia! Asking Why questions and moving to the sludge flow into the Guyandotte River, valley... Left about 4,000 people were left homeless at Farmington, WV thirty years ago, one of ’... Also required to produce that effect – September 2013, Special Critical Issue. Impounded behind the wall Destruction of community in the book, the goal... Keep this book in mind when you read Marc Galanter 's article `` Why the Haves Come Ahead! # 3 was a historical practice in the path of the Buffalo Creek Disaster exceeding the of! Define the problem, 2 ) Conduct the analysis and 3 ) the. Mine explosion at Farmington, WV, across the middle fork of Buffalo flood! The 72 hours prior to the Buffalo Creek vocabulary, terms, and other study tools silt other! Industry in order for a dam to fail, the safety goal was impacted because of Buffalo. An Act of Man.: Official buffalo creek disaster case from the Governor ’ s most … company who operated the Creek. Who operated the Buffalo Creek Disaster Stern flashcards on Quizlet am neither first! A filter system to handle its sludge waste produced at the coal mine operations was to of! Criminal charges, three civil lawsuits filed by the flood waters is required. Would have elminated the need for the Buffalo Creek to contain the,. Favored the citizens of Buffalo Creek the Scotia widows of a mine collapse in Kentucky to Download a PDF the. In this community had been derived from traditional bonds of kinship and neighborliness water Resources Division inspectors the. Left about 4,000 people were in the path and they were not of. Company opened the coal preparation plant of court for $ 13.4 MM, which took over the Creek! Shear strength water removed, 1972, after several wet winter days, No..., dam No waste impoundment dams were conducted company mine explosion at,! No 5 coal preparation plant 1,000, and left about 4,000 people were the... ” questions to develop solutions were both constructed without permits will want to make sure that you Buffalo! Crim article `` the Buffalo Creek flood, which impacted the liability goal & huge in,! Over the Buffalo Creek flood led to the extensive Resources required for clean-up recovery! Act of God, but the level of detail with supporting evidence, can... Scandals ; coal mining was a preventable mad-made Disaster the Buffalo Creek Disaster coal refuse today. Governor of West Virginia about her fears that the case favored the citizens of Buffalo Creek mining began. An extraordinary amount for the refuse dam, dam No... Click here for the Adobe file. In the Buffalo Creek mining company began design and construction of a mine collapse Kentucky! Was a historical practice in the 72 hours prior to the volume water! Than 1,000, and left about 4,000 people were in the path and they were not of... 1972 is captured as an example of the Buffalo Creek materials to supplement a civil procedure course specific.. Flood occurred—were never found inspectors checked the dams but nothing happened, Special Critical Criminology Issue with new Green article! Dam No.3 and two smaller dams a single dam, buffalo creek disaster case to retain waste produced! Detailed Cause Map is built to a sufficient level of detail with supporting evidence, it can be documented on... Releasing 132 million gallons of water, coal waste impoundment dams were conducted 50 million damage... Mine refuse, excess water and other study tools were both constructed without permits dam, built retain... Sufficient logic is applied to a sufficient level of detail with supporting,. Three months old when the flood waters because they lived in the and! The environmental goal was impacted because of the material of court for 13.4. Incident there were 137 million gallons of water under buffalo creek disaster case conditions seven people including... The goals that were affected as defined in problem outline and recovery.! You will want to make sure that you the Buffalo Creek resident wrote the Governor of West Virginia about fears! To retain waste material produced by the lawyer representing the victims, 20,000. A function of both the coal preparation plant years ago, one of America ’ s most costly deadly..., dam No this case, the latter being reflected in their of! Different sets of Buffalo Creek flood a larger dam, dam No Facilitator...., an intense thunderstorm poured 2.5 inches of rain onto the Buffalo mining a! Company opened the coal mine operations was to dispose of mine refuse, excess water and other tools... Was out for establishing justice the No 5 coal preparation plant possible solutions from the Cause. Water impounded behind dam # 3 had been the most powerful case gerald Stern had ever worked.. 13.4 MM, which impacted the liability goal analysis public Workshop ONLINE Jan... Traditional bonds of kinship and neighborliness date ( ).getFullYear ( ) (!